Discover Bay Island Life 

Welcome to Bay Island, one of the most scenic and desirable waterfront neighborhoods in Virginia Beach’s Great Neck area. Surrounded by the Lynnhaven River and Broad Bay, Bay Island offers a relaxed, coastal lifestyle defined by boating, sunsets, and the natural beauty of the water. With its mix of classic homes, modern renovations, and deep-water properties, this neighborhood is perfect for those who love the water but still want to be minutes from top-rated schools, shopping, and dining.

 

Whether you’re looking for a luxury waterfront estate with a private dock or a charming inland home with neighborhood appeal, Bay Island captures the essence of coastal living in Virginia Beach. Explore the latest listings below and discover why so many residents fall in love with life on Bay Island. 

About Bay Island in Virginia Beach 

Situated along the Lynnhaven River just off Shore Drive and Great Neck Road, Bay Island is a well-established waterfront community known for its boating culture, beautiful scenery, and strong sense of community. The neighborhood includes a mix of waterfront and non-waterfront homes, many featuring private docks and direct access to Broad Bay and the Chesapeake Bay.

 

Schools: Bay Island residents are served by some of Virginia Beach’s top schools, including John B. Dey Elementary, Great Neck Middle, and Frank W. Cox High School — part of the highly regarded Great Neck school district. 

 

Location: Bay Island’s prime position places it just minutes from the Chesapeake Bay beaches, First Landing State Park, and Great Neck’s shopping and dining. With quick access to Shore Drive and North Great Neck Road, it’s convenient to both the Oceanfront and major commuter routes.

 

With its combination of natural beauty, tight-knit community, and prime waterfront access, Bay Island is one of the most unique and coveted neighborhoods in all of Virginia Beach. 

Bay Island – Neighborhood Insights 

Location & History
 
Located between Broad Bay and Long Creek, Bay Island offers one of Virginia Beach’s most picturesque residential settings. Originally developed in the 1950s and 1960s, the neighborhood has grown into a vibrant community where waterfront living meets suburban comfort.
 
Over time, Bay Island has evolved from a quiet fishing and boating community into one of Virginia Beach’s premier residential areas — a place where residents still wave to neighbors while cruising by boat or walking the island’s peaceful streets. 
Community & Lifestyle
 
Bay Island is known for its strong community spirit. The Bay Island Civic League hosts events throughout the year - from neighborhood socials and holiday parades to volunteer cleanups and community watch programs — fostering connection among residents.
 
Life here revolves around the water. Boating, kayaking, paddleboarding, and crabbing are part of everyday living. Many homes have direct water access, while others enjoy scenic views of the creeks, marshes, and abundant wildlife.
 
It’s common to see residents out walking dogs, biking, or stopping to chat by the water — Bay Island is that kind of neighborhood.
Architecture & Real Estate
 
Homes in Bay Island range from mid-century ranches and cottages to luxury waterfront estates. Many properties have been updated or rebuilt to showcase modern coastal design and open floor plans. Large lots, mature trees, and private docks are common, giving each property a sense of space and individuality.
 
Home prices typically range from the mid-$600,000s to over $2 million, depending on size, location, and water access. Deep-water homes with docks and expansive views are among the most sought-after in Virginia Beach. 
Schools & Family Life
 
Families in Bay Island enjoy access to top-rated Virginia Beach schools: 

● John B. Dey Elementary School 
● Great Neck Middle School 
● Frank W. Cox High School 
 
These schools consistently earn high marks for academic achievement, extracurricular programs, and community involvement. Cox High’s Environmental Studies Academy is also a popular choice for students with an interest in marine science and sustainability — a fitting  theme for island life.

Current Homes for Sale in Bay Island

 

More Listings
More Listings

Request Private Tour

Andrew Christie
Andrew Christie

Broker Associate | License ID: 0225199734

+1(757) 502-5077

4416 Expressway Drive, Beach, VA, 23452, United States

Name
Phone*
Message

By checking this box, I agree by electronic signature to the Electronic Disclosure Consent Agreement; to receive recurring marketing communication from The Coastal Collective @ Atlantic Sotheby's International Realty, including auto-dialed calls, texts, and artificial/prerecorded voice messages (message frequency varies; data rates may apply; reply "STOP" to opt-out of texts or "HELP" for assistance); and to the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy of this website. Consent not required to make a purchase. I understand that I can call to obtain direct assistance.

FAQs

Where is Bay Island located?

Just off Shore Drive in Virginia Beach’s Great Neck area, between Broad Bay and Long Creek. 

When was the neighborhood developed? 

What types of homes are there?

What are typical home prices?

What makes the neighborhood special?

Which schools serve Bay Island? 

How’s the community engagement?

What recreational amenities are nearby?

REVIEWS

Harry Heinke

Excellent service by Andrew - made great suggestions upon listing my property and followed up on all prospects + helped me manage things as I was absentee from the area. Recommended !

TROY LOYD

Andrew was both helpful and a great negotiator. He spends an enormous amount of time to make sure that selling the property is at the right, agressive price. He, also, works to make sure that a seller's intent is understood and supported throughout the entire process.

If you want to have a realtor that advocates for you as a seller and will guarantee you best return on property, Andrew is the person to have as your representative!

lorianneyoung22

My home was in VA and I live in California. Andrew and his team were amazing in helping me sell the home without me being there. I could not have asked for a better experience.